“We’re very, very concerned. It’s very out of character,” a colleague said. The words, spoken during what was meant to be a routine well-being check, captured the unease that set everything in motion.
According to records obtained through public records requests and reported by The Columbus Dispatch, Columbus police received the first call at 9:03 a.m. on December 30, 2025, when a colleague requested a well-being check on Spencer Tepe, who had not arrived at work and could not be reached by phone.
For those who knew Spencer’s habits, the silence alone was enough to raise concern.
A patrol car on the streets of Columbus, Ohio. | Source: Getty Images
A Missed Routine That Prompted the First Check
Spencer worked at Athens Dental Depot, which opens at 8 a.m., on Tuesdays. The caller told dispatchers it was entirely out of character for him to miss work without notice.
“He is always on time and he would contact us if there was any issue whatsoever,” the colleague said in the call to the police. “I just don’t know how else to say this.” An officer arrived at the home on the 1400 block of North 4th Street around 9:22 a.m., found no response at the door, and left.
The photo of a dental office. | Source: Getty Images
When Concern Turned Into Alarm
As the morning progressed and Spencer remained unreachable, the concern that began at his workplace spread beyond it. By 9:57 a.m., another call came in, this time from a man at the residence who reported hearing children inside the house. At 10 a.m., another coworker called the police, saying she was worried about the dentist’s well-being and was heading to the residence.
At 10:05 am, a friend called the police from the home. He said he went there because Spencer was not answering the phone. According to dispatcher recordings, the caller said he could see a body inside the house, lying near a bed. “There is a body inside,” the caller stated.
Police returned to the home, located two young children inside, and executed a search warrant at the residence. What they found next would confirm the worst fears raised by the earlier calls.
Columbus police patrol car seen in Ohio. | Source: Getty Images
Who Was Found Inside the Home
Authorities later confirmed that Spencer, 37, and his wife, Monique Tepe, 39, were found dead inside their Weinland Park home. Spencer had been shot multiple times, according to a police radio run log obtained by The Dispatch.
A police dispatcher report also referenced a “41A,” a code used for robbery reports. Police said there were no indications of a murder-suicide but declined to release further details. As of December 31, 2025, Columbus police had not returned The Dispatch’s follow-up calls.
As investigators worked to piece together what happened, attention also turned to the lives interrupted by the violence.
Who Spencer and Monique Were
Spencer’s staff profile reportedly listed him as a dentist at the dental depot in Athens, Ohio. He earned bachelor’s degrees in Spanish and biology from The Ohio State University and completed his Doctor of Dental Surgery there in 2017.
“Outside of the office, Dr. Tepe enjoys golf, travel, and time with his family,” the profile reportedly stated. The dental office closed on Friday to mourn his death.
A photo of Spencer and Monique Tepe’s residence, seen from a video post dated January 5, 2026. | Source: YouTube/WKYCChannel3
What Investigators Have Ruled Out
While many questions remain unanswered, police have publicly addressed a few key points. In a report by WKYC, investigators said they have ruled out a murder-suicide, have not publicly named any suspects, and are treating the case as a homicide. Police have not confirmed whether a robbery occurred, nor have they explained how the suspect may have entered the home.
According to a New York Post report, investigators believe the suspect may have been captured on a police camera mounted on a utility pole near the intersection of Fourth Street and East Eighth Avenue, just a few hundred feet from the home. The report said there were no signs of forced entry, and the suspect quickly fled the area. Police have not confirmed the footage publicly.
Neighbors Describe a Shaken Block
As details emerged, residents nearby began grappling with the reality that the violence occurred so close to home. Residents nearby told The Dispatch the neighborhood is typically quiet.
Andrew Pla, who lived next door, said he was away when the shooting occurred and described feeling unsettled upon learning what happened.
Across the street, Ethan Garcia said he often saw Monique leaving for work in the mornings and described the news as deeply concerning.
Police crime tape is use across Spencer and Monique Tepe’s home, seen from a video post dated January 5, 2026. | Source: YouTube/WKYCChannel3
Family Speaks as Community Grieves
For those closest to the couple, the shock quickly gave way to grief. A family member described shock, anger, and despair as investigators continue their work. Rob Misleh said:
“They were so warm. Their place in Columbus was just where everybody gathered. They always had people over, always having fun, just great people. They’re just amazing parents and their kids are beautiful, but they, they did such a great job, and you know we have a huge community that now will obviously step in and help raise these children.”
Rob Misleh talks about Spencer and Monique Tepe, seen from a video post dated January 5, 2026. | Source: YouTube/WKYCChannel3
A GoFundMe page created by Audrey (Tepe) Mackie, a cousin, described the couple as deeply connected to others and devoted parents.
Mark Valrose, the owner of Athens Dental Depot, also stated, “He will be deeply missed by our team and the many patients he cared for over the years.”
An Online Detail Drawing Attention
As the investigation unfolded, an online claim began circulating. On X, a handle claimed that someone had searched Monique’s name online roughly 12 hours before the killings.
Police have not commented on the claim or confirmed whether it is relevant to the investigation. Days after the shooting, key questions remain unanswered: who entered the home, why, and whether the children witnessed anything that could help investigators.
For now, police say the case remains active, and a community is left grappling with the sudden loss of two lives — and the silence surrounding how it all happened.
In the end, what began as a colleague’s quiet worry, a missed shift, and an unanswered phone has left behind far larger questions than answers. Until more details emerge, the case remains defined not only by what is known, but also by what is missing and by the lingering unease that something so devastating could have unfolded from a moment that first seemed merely out of character.